Pushed Too Far

Feb 18, 2021
108 949 Views

The plaintiff says she gave the defendant a security deposit to rent his home, but she backed out when she discovered he was a crackhead. She claims he threatened her with a gun when she asked for her money back, so she’s suing for the deposit and emotional distress. The defendant claims he tried to return her money and denies ever pulling a gun. He’s countersuing for false arrest.

  • I think it was lies told on both sides,he said she didn't know he had a gun,but then said he wears it on his side.She left and didn't go to court,why would you leave and not go to court,he said he didn't know how she knew he had 2 guns,they surpose to search you right then and there I taught,why wouldn't your mom be in court with you?And why you wouldn't get the witness statements before you even went to court the first time you didn't know you was going to judge Mathis until you lost in the other courts,why would you risk that the first time?I believe both of them told lies.

    Pamela ShortPamela Short17 hours ago
  • I love the southern accent!

    19791979Day ago
  • He's definitely a LIAR, with crackhead tendencies.

    Travis MaxwellTravis MaxwellDay ago
  • You can tell he is a wanna be, but isn’t. He been watching too many rap videos and wants to be slick. He is gonna run into the wrong person. When he called her baby in the hallway, I wanted to jump through this phone and jack him up. For the nerve to have a girlfriend. You can tell he wanna be a player, but ain’t got the goods.

    Dorothye KnoxDorothye KnoxDay ago
  • Acts 17:30 The times of ignorance God overlooked, but now he commands all people everywhere to repent, 31 because he has fixed a day on which he will judge the world in righteousness by a man whom he has appointed; and of this he has given assurance to all by raising him from the dead.” Romans 3:23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus. 1 John 1:9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. Acts 16:30 Then he brought them out and said, “Sirs, what must I do to be saved?” And they said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household. Repent therefore and trust Jesus Christ as your Saviour and your Lord. True repentance involves achange of heart which includes sorrow for sin and determination to lead a holy life, Christ deliver the repentant person from sin's penalty by dying on the cross. If not, you will be judged by the law, and everyone has violated the law of God one way or the other , if you do not turn to Christ wholeheartedly : you won't escape the harsh judgement of God because you have despised the redemptive work of Jesus Christ the Saviour of the whole world. Hebrews 10:26 For if we go on sinning deliberately after receiving the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, 27 but a fearful expectation of judgment, and a fury of fire that will consume the adversaries. Grace and love from God in Jesus Christ be multiplied in your heart you all.

    Come to Jesus before it is too lateCome to Jesus before it is too lateDay ago
  • He might be a crack head, but she is on section 8 herself and pregnant. And she had to do business with him so she could have a place to stay. And 3 of her cases were already dismissed or thrown out, but all of a sudden she is able to produce witness statements for her side? I think both of them are lying to some degree, and both of them are guilty of the other's accusations, that is why I am fine with the judge giving the ruling he did.

    DarkEpyon123DarkEpyon1232 days ago
  • Uncle Headcrack is really weird!

  • He's sounds like Morgan Freeman

    Jaiza JJaiza J3 days ago
  • She has bad results every time she go to court, thats so embarrassing

    bambieyeddbambieyedd3 days ago
  • Now unc Greg! This lady should have gotten her money back! He’s def giving me crackhead vibes! She should have brought her mother with her as a witness

    Life In The Jazz LaneLife In The Jazz Lane4 days ago
  • Out of all the cases this is the one Judge Mathis decides not to call someone a crackhead 🥴🥴😑😑

    Stephanie RamirezStephanie Ramirez4 days ago
  • That man is gross and condescending.

    Aye FoAye Fo4 days ago
  • Sometimes Judge Mathis doesn't listen. Too busy trying to pull out the ratchetness. The man is clearly a liar. Judge Mathis: Why do you carry 2 guns? Defendant: ah ah ah I work in ah ah ah I live in an area ?????

    Kimberly WilsonKimberly Wilson4 days ago
  • The after verdict tho I'm dead😂💀 #PoBaby

    Jaxk BoiiZJaxk BoiiZ5 days ago
  • Definitely didn’t like how he disrespected her mom by calling her a linebacker. Plus, Mathis didn’t even correct him. Judge Mathis chooses when he wants to go off on certain people 🤷🏾‍♂️

    Dez BDez B5 days ago
  • The lewd duckling pivotally slow because plaster temporarily poke atop a flat shrine. hushed, accessible woolen

    Joe SmithJoe Smith5 days ago
  • Wow

    Bonnie BundlesBonnie Bundles5 days ago
  • 😂 defended look like Red Foxx in Harlem Night.

    A JA J5 days ago
  • I believe she did act a fool because she didn’t get her money back in cash and his old self match her energy! They were in Winn-Dixie parking lot acting a fool for a house in the hood! I agree with Judge both of y’all don’t get nothing

    SunRae_PSunRae_P5 days ago
  • Hell no. I disagree with Judge Mathis on this issue. This man should pay her the deposit back period

    Peter P5Peter P55 days ago
  • Lol at the end he said poor Thang I'm going to pray for you lmfao

    Mo carringtonMo carrington5 days ago
  • omg he is stuttering so bad , you can tell he got crackish ways 🤦🏽‍♀️

    Darielle WhitleyDarielle Whitley5 days ago
  • Judge Mathis you were dead wrong on this case!

    Journeys AlkebulanJourneys Alkebulan6 days ago
  • This is a very old case.

    Journeys AlkebulanJourneys Alkebulan6 days ago
  • Judge was totally wrong on this one. It was clear the man was as guilty as could be. He did pull a gun on that young lady that’s why she knew about the gun. I love love judge Mathis but that was the wrong call

    Janice LewisJanice Lewis6 days ago
  • Couldn't bring a witness statements to back her case to the judge, back home...on 2 different occasions. All of a sudden, she has witness statements to bring to Judge Mathis...even more months later.

    Bray JayBray Jay6 days ago
  • Judge Mathis needs medication , his bipolarism is getting worst

    Joe TraxxJoe Traxx6 days ago
  • @6:00 I can see the look in his eyes that he actually pulled the pistol out. She made that good brother lose his religion!😆

    BigMerkGeeBigMerkGee7 days ago
  • She looks a little bit like the rapper Yo-Yo from back in the day.

    EricaYE6EricaYE67 days ago
  • That young lady wasn't lying. He tried the cheat her out of her money by giving her a post dated check!! The reason a person would do that is because at the time the give you a check there are no funds in their account! And he just happened to have 2 guns on him?!? he judge got it wrong! Again!!!

    Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!7 days ago
  • His stuttering gave him away. Story was all over the place. He don't sound like such a helping person at all.

    marskeinsmarskeins7 days ago
  • He should have gotten $5,000. If she is on section 8, why should she get anything the taxpayer is supporting?

    Steve SavickiSteve Savicki7 days ago
  • Dad had 2 pistols on him. You have to watch who you're talking to

    The 5-Star ReviewThe 5-Star Review7 days ago
  • Her victory laugh was short-lived. Lol!

    juantubeyjuantubey7 days ago
  • I believed her, this is a shame. He know he waved them guns at her.

    ShanShan8 days ago
  • I just came here to say I love the defendant’s accent 😂😂

    Tashana PinkTashana Pink8 days ago
    • Lmao!!!

      juantubeyjuantubey7 days ago
  • Defendant's wife is a chump lol, he'll wave that gun at her too

    SpiffyPenguinSpiffyPenguin8 days ago
  • He's shady....she's shady.....good verdict.

    Rio DRio D8 days ago
  • She's telling the truth about him. How did JM fall for that?

    Jennifer BrandonJennifer Brandon8 days ago
    • @Nellie K. Adaba He acts like a functioning addict and holy roller to me. He put a suit on to come to court but I believe what she said about how he acts.

      Jennifer BrandonJennifer Brandon7 days ago
    • He doesn't look like a crackhead to me, so I don't know.

      Nellie K. AdabaNellie K. Adaba7 days ago
  • I had to watch this one again. She said she paid the LAST installment on a Friday. Obviously he wasn't as creepy as she claimed.

    cynthia hickscynthia hicks8 days ago
  • How many crackheads actually carry guns?? I'm sure he would have sold them BOTH and the holster for crack?? And then to come back after the first confrontation?? Doesn't sound believable to me. And the case got dismissed.

    cynthia hickscynthia hicks8 days ago
  • For all the ones saying the guy was a crackhead or has crackish ways... y'all know good and darn well Judge Mathis would have called him out with NO hesitation!!!

    cynthia hickscynthia hicks8 days ago
    • Not any more!

      Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!7 days ago
  • And she still moved in after that first impression hell naw thats a red flag

    Christy MarshallChristy Marshall8 days ago
  • He did that shit JM was wrong

    Lenedra LawrenceLenedra Lawrence8 days ago
  • Judge missed his chance to actually call a crackhead a crackhead

    osean Fergusonosean Ferguson8 days ago
  • Bastets????😂😂

    Rome60 Rome60Rome60 Rome609 days ago
  • The proper way is to pay her by check, given the fact he owns a real estate company.

    Jerry Flynn DaleJerry Flynn Dale9 days ago
    • @Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!! where do I send the check.

      Jerry Flynn DaleJerry Flynn Dale7 days ago
    • @Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!, We all know she would have said she didn’t receive a refund, lol.

      Jerry Flynn DaleJerry Flynn Dale7 days ago
    • I own a bridge that I would love to sell you! Think about it!!!

      Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!7 days ago
  • He from mobile al 😂😂😂 he most def a con artist crack head

    Israelite PrincessIsraelite Princess9 days ago
  • The FIRST judge dismissed the case, Judge Mathis said that his arrest was maliciously retaliatory. SHE LIED, that's WHY she lost her cases.

    5THEGIRLZ5THEGIRLZ9 days ago
  • judge mathis is very bias when a black woman is suing a black man, I think that he identifies with the men and give them break because he knows what it’s like to be a black man in America, he pity them and give them more credibility than some deserve. But, he hates black women who appear as confrontational or “ghetto” and judge them by their appearances instead of the case. He’s not as impartial as other TV judges like Judge Milian. Sometimes it’s good because he help people that needs it but sometimes it’s bad because his emotions make him rule for the liar as long he liked him. So it’s more based on whether he likes you or not than the law.

    Lily RoseLily Rose9 days ago
    • She had no evidence in her case and she lied on her first case to the previous Judge stop whining for black women the ones who do the dirt get what they deserve I swear you're a broken record 😴

      Zeto KaibaZeto Kaiba8 days ago
  • Bad Call JM 🤯😕

    Elle 7Elle 79 days ago
  • Creepy but you gave him your money.

    Charisse JohnsonCharisse Johnson9 days ago
    • Because having a place to live is important to some people

      Iam JustmeIam Justme9 days ago
  • WRONG JUDGEMENT Greg !!!!!, THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF SOME CORRUPT JUDGES WHO ARE MEMBERS OF demonic secret organizations WHO FAVORS OTHER demonic secret organizations brotherhood members . THIS NARCISSISTIC demon IS A DRUG ADDICT WHO COMMITTED FRAUD AGAINST THE INNOCENT , BUT HE SEEMS TO BE FAVORED BY some demonic police officers WHO ARE ALSO IN A demonic fraternity. GOD's JUDGEMENT IS UPON THE wicked !

    Kindest RegardsKindest Regards9 days ago
  • Judge Got it WRONG! He just happened to have TWO guns on his person.... 2!!!!! Come on now.

    bndrbrnbndrbrn9 days ago
  • The guy is not completely innocent. But I think the woman is an instigator. I’ve been around people that for whatever reason, like to slander others. She roused up a problem. And he could’ve reacted unprofessionally. Than the plaintiff used it against him. I feel she’s more guilty than him.

  • I have a major problem paying someone in cash and the situation arises where the money has to be repaid but they choose to repay me by check. Some banks take a week before they clear checks and if it's a bounce check you could find yourself having to go through a lot of rigmarole to recover your money.

    Clarence EdwardsClarence Edwards9 days ago
  • In had the Birmingham board of education give me a check misspellings and put me out asking for a corrected then captain d's gave me a counterfeit 10 they mailed me replacement from my receipt maybe they knew or found the person ahead of me because right after I took the 10 to my am south bank when laundry used the pen put on news bad money same day. It's been a problem with my molester daughter ironing wire coats her mother says a unit nurse who don't wear coats with names then my boyfriend I met at the hospital the angry mother retired from says to me one time his ex told the police he attacked her in the laundry room. And that his girlfriend met at the gas station married told him never to wear cologne and shower for money when I met a girl at the gas station who hit me in the temple twice with a ring on different times riding in car and sitting in hair chair the youth minister gave me while dating plus my exlarrt dad is a preacher too. The girls brother cut the ring finger off to get the ring and the molester was standing in shower door in her bathroom not the front bathroom across from his wife's bedroom while I was asked to spend the night. My high school teacher was superintendent of the board when they accused me of sex with girls but never happened. Then when Reuben studdard won from same high school as the daughter I saw him on 1st street going to get a res rolling suitcase from my mother's loft apartment. He rolled the window down and spoke and I got to apartment in Westwood on landfair the roommate said I broke her lamp by putting it on top of my suitcase to fall.over so I went and found the IKEA store in Burbank to buy another to keep the peace obviously already chaotic the first day. I told the police her dad looked like the actor in tv show fake wedding that they tricked the bride. When I was suspended in 5th grade for the teacher sending me next door with the girl who lived there but teacher lied saying did not and I was the only one suspended and paddkedcwith brut angry force 10 times that ultimately after another 5 years busted tailbone coccyx trainings at brookwood the later said never happened when arrested in that same hospital and another surgery also. They got on the stand and said I was imagining and trying to accuse people of rape. I said at that time medical rape forcing me to do stuff to get paperwork. In high school surgery stemming from elementary they paraded 10 student doctor's in with me exposed and I was not told ahead or time nor my mother I believe are still in working places with intenrmtions for the molesters wife deliciousness. The man even saw,me one day at the gas station in 1991 from 1981 and said you want to do something made me angry and said no walkungbaway he said of you need me I'll be at the apartments up the street. My youth pastor fraternity brother asked same thing wanna,do something that he had following me in auburn university very jealous. And me and rifle both in mental health married to nurses. Another ex said those same apartments told in 1991 but in 2006 before my first arrest was the place to buy weed and I thought strange because she don't smoke marijuana and I don't drink and never used cocaine. I told my teammate while in Cali waiting on cab about the roommate when she was over americorp at the board of education and the dart is church son was over jobcorp and became president of my bank bought out and shut my account and email and phones down. I was asking him last month found his number to to hear him say I was,never a who're around the church and his mother called right after that so we hung up.

    Lisa PerdueLisa Perdue9 days ago
  • Oh and he was mad or had an attitude bc he had to give her 💰 back. Smh

    Modestine MungoModestine Mungo9 days ago
  • Who pushes a pregnant 👩. ..Dang shr still pregnant. When is the baby due? Lookin like now!! Hurry up!!

    Modestine MungoModestine Mungo9 days ago

    SocialbuttafliSocialbuttafli9 days ago
  • I actually believe the defendant....she seems like she's messy messy MESSY...

    Panamaya Saint BPanamaya Saint B9 days ago
    • @Iam Justme Still won though lol 💀

      Zeto KaibaZeto Kaiba8 days ago
    • And the defendant is messy messy & MESSIER

      Iam JustmeIam Justme9 days ago
  • It’s thanksgiving weekend I was getting ready to have my turkey lmao

    kenneth archibaldkenneth archibald9 days ago
  • I’m done with judge Mathis. He award that crackhead money.

    Cassie WCassie W9 days ago
  • Judge Mathis dropped the ball on this one

    Randi MarshalsRandi Marshals9 days ago
  • He is lying! Everything people say just might be true. He believes he is SLICK

    Randi MarshalsRandi Marshals9 days ago
  • “At some point you might wanna say NO!” 😂😂😂😂 lmfao

    Mannequinn_MadeMannequinn_Made10 days ago
  • 🗣 I Can't Stand Men That Take Advantage Of Women. #COWARD

    MaxMax10 days ago
  • I Don't Know How Americans Celebrate Black Friday But In South Africa Businesses Are Definently Not Closed On That Day, That's When They Milk Consumers And Cash In The Most. Lowered Prices.😂

    Nico SekanoNico Sekano10 days ago
  • Why she wanted cash instead of a check it shouldn't have mattered bc either way she got her money. She must've been dead broke or something bc he did do EXACTLY what she asked. Most business people NEVER even deal with cash, but they will accept money orders or checks smh! She got mad not him therefore I do feel like she caused the altercation.

    DIVINEbyNATURE nicoleDIVINEbyNATURE nicole10 days ago
  • JM, you have lost your asking plp are they a crackhead card. You disrespect so many plp with that question and bagger them even, laughing and all, even when they say no you keep going. Now you have one in front of you knows how to play the game, suit waaay too big bought at the last minute no monies available had to post date the check and you blew it. Now she put a little extra sauce on her story but he definitely playing that flute.

    Playa SmurfPlaya Smurf10 days ago
  • 🤣🤣😂😂 "Po Baby"!! 🤣🤣😂😂

    Oba HodariOba Hodari10 days ago
  • There are functional addicts among us.

    Sturkelious RronSturkelious Rron10 days ago
  • I believe him She's really annoying...

    Cee DeeCee Dee10 days ago
  • He sounds like Pastor Jamal Bryant and looks as if He could be related.

    Sho NuffSho Nuff10 days ago
  • It’s sad how much we weaponize drug addiction and attempt to embarrass those who are addicted but this woman is already on section 8 and is standing in court pregnant. Let’s discuss the problem with that.

    Felicia The ArtistFelicia The Artist10 days ago
  • I tried to give that baby her money back!!!!!! LOL

    MRTLEW01MRTLEW0110 days ago
  • Wow Judge Mathis is aging backwards.....good for him:)

    Yvette4ChristYvette4Christ10 days ago
    • Not mentally!

      Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!7 days ago
  • Lmbo at the defendant!! Im from Alabama and that’s PA(Prichard, Al) all day‼️🤣

    MsBdoll87MsBdoll8710 days ago
  • All these comments talking bout he did it and etc...,,, was y’all there? We so quick to judge someone we don’t know after 13:23 🤦🏽‍♂️😂🤣😂

    Skylark1968Skylark196810 days ago
  • Dude is on something

    Island Girl RubyIsland Girl Ruby10 days ago
  • She looks likes she's pregnant, hopefully she's not carrying this man seed.

    Jean Baptiste AsongJean Baptiste Asong10 days ago
    • Jean Bapiste Asong Where did you come to that conclusion?? 🤔

      Eugenia BooneEugenia Boone9 days ago
  • Dude definitely did this... judge is definitely trippin about this one

    awallbabyawallbaby10 days ago
  • Somebody Raised you better than that 😅🤣🤣😅😅😆😅🤣🤣😂

    gregory cobbgregory cobb10 days ago
  • He definitely pulled the gun on that woman. She may have gotten loud with him about the check but he pulled that gun. Why did he say “that baby” like that 😂😂😂

    Mademoiselle_ TamiMademoiselle_ Tami10 days ago
  • I agree with the judge lol

    Christa ArmsteadChrista Armstead10 days ago
  • Po baby! I'm dead

    maxx starrdommaxx starrdom10 days ago
  • If not crack, he smokes meth!

    caroline mageecaroline magee10 days ago
  • Mathis was wrong for that judgement...

    Starlett ProudStarlett Proud10 days ago
  • JM YOU WRONG. I believe that man brandished that weapon. And he’s powder head 🙄 she’s out of $7k and I pray god blesses her with $14k.

    Logan HoughLogan Hough10 days ago
    • Who said $7k??

      cynthia hickscynthia hicks8 days ago
  • It’s how he look over the glasses for me

    Nekeiah MeltonNekeiah Melton10 days ago
  • This is what I'm talking about! You can go into the archives !! Like we just want to see JM we dont care about the time period

    Skarlet BrownSkarlet Brown10 days ago
  • Funny it was never brought up again that she was talking to a crack dealer why?!!!

    El TownEl Town10 days ago
    • @aaprii333 Because they are PEOPLE and they live in the neighborhood.

      Iam JustmeIam Justme9 days ago
    • My sentiments EXACTLY!🤨🤨🤨

      aaprii333aaprii33310 days ago
  • *Man goes home strips into boxer and wife beater and smokes crack*

    Michael Trey WrightMichael Trey Wright10 days ago
  • Black Friday is NOT a banking holiday! The banks are closed on Thanksgiving! He's telling the truth. She saw his holster and used that to claim that he waved a gun around at her. He had two or three witnesses for his court dates. She had NONE!

    Needed To Be SaidNeeded To Be Said10 days ago
  • So the judge listened that whole case and still said it was a malicious arrest???? Ok. 🤦🏽‍♀️ . He rules out of emotions almost all the time.....it's sad to see because persons don't really ever get justice when this is done.

    Felisha SampsonFelisha Sampson10 days ago
    • Cases are usually dismissed because of a lack of evidence. Dismissals have nothing to do with emotions. As a matter of fact - if a judge can't rule on a case base solely on the evidence and not his/her emotions it would be time for that judge to retire!

      Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!Eva Co Thank you, Anthony!!!7 days ago
    • So the first judge ruled on emotions too? Or didn't you hear that the case was dismissed?

      juantubeyjuantubey7 days ago
  • I don’t agree w/ JM on this. Everything she said about him was proven by his actions on this case. His story was all over the place, he was stuttering and acting like a weirdo. Plus as soon as he granted the verdict she broke down crying.

    inukoko2012inukoko201210 days ago
    • She won her case but he had 3 store employees testimonies for false arrest. He could have countered defamation for saying he a crackhead with no evidence.

      KD MACKD MAC2 days ago
  • He asked me if I had a boyfriend, camera spans out to her belly. Bwahahaha

    Royal HeritageRoyal Heritage10 days ago
  • @1247 wtf!😂😂 Dat dude😉 at the monitor 🤣😂

    jaquan liljonjaquan liljon10 days ago
  • Judge got this one wrong🤔, that nigga shadier than a awning and shes already on section 8 and pregnant I don’t think she can afford to loose that 6 hundred?! 😕🤷🏽‍♂️

    Dennis SmithDennis Smith10 days ago
  • JM sucks sometimes.

    Kira IronsKira Irons10 days ago